Last year, I tried a new eggnog recipe, based on Alton Brown’s aged eggnog recipe, which used a dozen raw egg yolks. The thought was to add a lot of alcohol to the mix, and then let it sit in the fridge for several weeks, in the hopes of eliminating any salmonella from the raw eggs. But the fact is, the only surefire way of getting rid of salmonella is by heating the eggnog to 160°. There’s just not enough alcohol in this holiday drink to eliminate salmonella. So, if you’re wary about eating raw eggs, you shouldn’t use them in eggnog, thinking the alcohol will take care of the bad stuff. It won’t.
My own eggnog recipe, based on my friend, Rick’s, recipe, which was based on his father’s recipe, has changed over the years. I, too, used to use raw eggs. But now I go by a different method.
This recipe is absolutely delicious but is also a heart attack in a glass. I updated this recipe so that you don’t need to worry about salmonella (because you’re not using raw eggs)…though the alcohol will certainly still get you!
The solution is to buy pasteurized eggs.

Some supermarkets now carry whole eggs in the shell that have been pasteurized, though they are hard to find. But the Whole Foods near me does carry pasteurized real whole liquid eggs under the Vital Farms name, and they work perfectly with this recipe. (Old eggnog recipes often used only the egg yolk, but others used the whole egg. I found that these liquid eggs work beautifully.) The original recipe called for 15 raw eggs. A 16-oz. container of Vital Farms liquid eggs is the same as about 9 eggs. So I need one full 16 oz. container, and then another 10 oz. or so for this recipe.

1.5 quarts vanilla ice cream
1 pint half & half
Just over 26 oz. Vital Farms liquid whole eggs (the equivalent of 15 whole raw eggs)
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
1/4 cup pure maple syrup
6 oz. of each:
spiced rum (I use Captain Morgan)
whiskey (I use Crown Royal)
brandy (I use E&J)
I let the ice cream soften one day in the fridge. I carefully mix the ice cream, half-and-half, eggs, vanilla, cinnamon and nutmeg in a blender.
My blender is pretty big, but I find that it’s full at this point. So I pour everything into a gallon-size glass jar.
To the jar, I add the maple syrup and all the liquor. Then I whisk everything together, making sure I get down to the bottom of the jar.

After it’s fully mixed, I place the lid on the jar, and move the eggnog to the fridge, where I let it sit for at least 12-24 hours for the flavors to blend. Even longer is better.
One final mix and taste to determine whether I want more cinnamon, nutmeg or maple syrup, and it’s good to go!

And by the way, it’s pretty darn tasty with coffee! Just imagine a variation on a White Russian, with eggnog and freshly brewed coffee, and a bit of a drizzle of maple syrup on top!
Cheers!































